I think you've got an interesting idea here, but can I suggest a way of doing this?
You've told us The Butter Battle Book is a particularly good book by Dr Seuss, but it's one of his I've never heard about. How about a synopsis and your reasons for rating it so highly?
Convince us that we need to read this book.
How about giving us your top five books by this author?
I'm currently reading The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society by Mary Ann Shaffer and Annie Barrows - in that book the members of the society each read a book and then try to persuade the other members to read the same one. Once more than one person has read it, they are able to discuss the positive or negative sides of the book and maybe persuade even more members to read it.
So - tell us more about The Butter Battle Book and why it means so much to you.