by Exp. Date, the rat » Wed Feb 24, 2010 7:46 am
I like Nigel for the 'feel' of the Discworld. he has just the right comic edge in his voice for the stories, and some of his voices are spot on. HIs Nanny Ogg , Colon, Nobby and Vimes are just as I imagined them. HIs Detritus is good to as the un-educated early watchman.
But as Detritus got 'smarter' Briggies DT is much better, and the same goes with his Vimes. Nigel's Vimes had the street wise drunkered while Briggies' Vimes is the rough edged aristocrat that he has grown into.
I do not like SB's Colon. He sounds too stupid, but his Nobby is just like Nigels so no loss there. I do agree that SB's reading is sometimes too flat but his range of all the different speices is GREAT! The best to show this work is 5th Elephant with all the WWW, Vamps, Dwarfs. Also good is The Truth with Otto which I LOVE!
I Love SB's Lut-ze which is excatly how I imagnied him to sound like.
Either way both have advantages and dis-advantages. Both help me get through the long nights at work and doing the house work as well.
A legal Feegle? How could there be such a thing?
Today I feel like I am soaring like a tortoise!