swreader wrote:But whether Vetinari actually participated in the Grand & Glorious Revolution before Sam's changes in history is, I think, impossible to decide one way or the other.
poohcarrot wrote:....but it isn't particularly funny! Soul Music has jokes on every page, NW doesn't.
I love NW, but I don't rate it even in the top 5 of TP's books.
I look forward to being convinced otherwise.
Lady V wrote:I think it is one of the best ones because it is not as funny as the others. Though to continue the PF theme from another thread the Dark Sarcasm is very funny. I love Time Travel things and so Vimes going back in time is absolutely brilliant and the twist that HE created the Paperwork he so despises is absolutely clever.
I love the Les Miserable feel about the whole thing and also how Cut Me Own Throat Dibbler got his catchphrase and the fact that it showed a pre-Vetinari Ankh Morpork ...
Personally I think it is one of his most clever novels.
Jan Van Quirm wrote:
Anyway I don't suppose that'll sway Pooh's views but majorities can be right...
poohcarrot wrote:You provide good argument, I will listen, if it's better than my opinion I'll change.
...and majorities can be wrong too.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 5 guests