Moffat has grown on me, but I do agree that he's far better as a writer than as a showrunner. In fact, he was, in general, a better writer before he became showrunner, though there have been exceptions.
But then again, every showrunner for the series since Verity Lambert have had their fans and detractors. Graham Williams and John Nathan-Turner have attracted more than their fair share of controversy, and often with better reason than RTD or Moffat.
All you need to understand
Is everything you know is wrong!
-Weird Al Yankovic