by LilMaibe » Wed Jun 15, 2011 6:31 pm
I think that is what defines a good writer:
The ability to create a living world (That is the main reason I dislike UA, every concept newly introduced in it is just dead).
I think Mr Pratchett once said it himself that he couldn't let AM burn down like it happened at the beginning of CoM as nowadays one would be aware of who's in danger inside the city walls. left alone who's likely dieing.
IMHO a good writer manages to make the world feel alive. This also includes the ability to handle all kinds of topics in various ways.
There are several authors out there that appear to be able to only paint in black and white. The good guys do good things, even if they are wrong and no matter what the bad guys do, it has to be evil in the long run.
In a 'dead' world themes like (assisted) suicide would likely be, if ever brought up, either be something only the bad guys do (to go with the general moral of the audience) or will get a very, very kitshy touch if the heroes do it (which then most often goes with, they do that so the guy who was forced by the bad guy to do evil things can go to heaven/whatever)