GUILDTY! the Ankh-Morpork Whodunnit Game

[Tina a.k.a.SusanSto.Helit]

Gawp,Gawp, Gawp!

[CrysaniaMajere]

I'd really like to believe Sjoerd... but the fact that he was laughing when he said I needn't fear him is not at all reassuring...

Anyway, why some of the known suspects (such as cols and TheL.) are not saying a word? WHERE ARE YOU?

[CrysaniaMajere]

I think i'd like to:
VOTE FOR THELIBRARIAN
because here, on Ankh-Morpork, the most suspicious thing of all is when someone keeps out of the way...
they are still in the 'game', right? so one of them, or even both, could be the killer..

[Lady Vetinari]

GAWPER ANKH MORPORK

Heard about this strange flu going round? Hog Flu from Klatch! Everyone got it ... The Librarian might be one of them ... after all Sandy, who knows Fergie who knows Mrs. Whitlow - well ... she told me that the Librarian is terrible ill! But you never know ....

[poohcarrot]

... yes, that's right, just not now please? I want to live in peace you know, I didn't mean anything back there... please don't kill me...

Additional Clues and Characters

If you look at the rules, Jan said there were additional clues in the list of characters. Also she said the two murderers have been given special instructions.

As already stated, Sjoerd's smiley looks like a man without an eye. Therefore he is Teatime, who also didn't have an eye. He was given the instruction to use this wink smiley when posting.

Now Mr Pin is famous for saying "...ing" all the time. What if the character playing Mr Pin was given special instructioins to use "..." when posting?

Both murderers would then be giving out their identity whenever they posted, laughing at the rest of us all the time.

If you look at the top post from CrysaniaMajere, you will see uses the "..." three times! She also uses it in ALL her other posts (5 in total).

Therefore Teatime is Sjoerd

And CrsaniaMajere is Mr Pin!

...ing clever or wot?

[bikkit]

Wasn't it tulip who said "...ing"

[Jan Van Quirm]

BIKKIT - YES

ALL MORTALS - THE CLUES ARE SIMPLY THOSE GIVEN ABOUT THE 4 PROTAGONIST CHARACTERS AS WRITTEN. NO TRICKYNESS!** *WAGS BONY FINGER AT POOH*


** ALTHOUGH THIS ONLY APPLIES TO WOT I WROTE... I MUST YET AGAIN PONDER ON THE PERNICIOUSNESS OF HUMANS IT SEEMS - TEATIME & PIN (& INDEED THE WATCH LADY/APE) MAY WELL HAVE ELABORATED ON THE INSTRUCTIONS ISSUED

[poohcarrot]

Wasn't it tulip who said "...ing"

Shhh! Don't ruin a good theory!

Anyway Bikkit, you suspiciously seem to know a lot about Mr Pin.

It was you, wasn't it?

[poohcarrot]

** ALTHOUGH THIS ONLY APPLIES TO WOT I WROTE... I MUST YET AGAIN PONDER ON THE PERNICIOUSNESS OF HUMANS IT SEEMS - TEATIME & PIN (& INDEED THE WATCH LADY/APE) MAY WELL HAVE ELABORATED ON THE INSTRUCTIONS ISSUED

HAHA!

So therefore Cols isn't one of the murderers, so if we all vote for Cols, it makes no difference if she gets thrown in the clink!

Let's all vote for Cols.

[poohcarrot]

I VOTE FOR COLS on the condition that Sjoerd (aka Murdering b*st*rd)) does likewise. If he votes for anyone else, my vote is for him

[Sjoerd3000]

I vote for Cols as prime suspect because I don't want to go to jail And if Pooh votes for me I will

[Jan Van Quirm]

Everyone (except pooh) especially Sjoerd - other thread a.s.a.p.

[Sjoerd3000]

I´m really reallly really innocent please believe me
and vote for Cols, if you vote for Cols I will send you a box of chocolates
(Is this allowed? hope it is )

[Dotsie]

I'm back! And I vote for cols. Chocolate, did you say?

[Sjoerd3000]

yes big box, very big box of chocolates