Moderators: Toothy, Tonyblack, Jason
Young adult Discworld books must be read at the time they were published

Tonyblack wrote:I'm not sure how the Wyrmberg idea is developed in G!G! The dragons both books are very different and from different origins.![]()
And yes, it's a very different style to the later books, mainly because Terry was writing parodies of existing fantasy books in the first few. The Wyrmberg for example seems to be a parody of Anne McCaffrey's Dragonrider boks.
Bouncy Castle wrote:Young adult Discworld books must be read at the time they were published
Dear Sir
Please supply one time machine.
Yours faithfully
Bouncy Castle (Miss)


poohcarrot wrote:Poohcarrot's mini blog![]()
1 The Colour of Magic 7
2 The Light Fantastic 7
3 Equal Rites 6
4 Mort 8
5 Sourcery 7
6 Wyrd Sisters 8
7 Pyramids 10
8 Guards! Guards! 10
9 Faust Eric 7
10 Moving Pictures 7
11 Reaper Man 7
12 Witches Abroad 9
13 Small Gods 9
14 Lords and Ladies 8
15 Men at Arms 8
16 Soul Music 10
17 Interesting Times 9
18 Maskerade 7
19 Feet of Clay 8
20 Hogfather 10
21 Jingo 10
22 The Last Continent 9
23 Carpe Jugulum 8
24 The Fifth Elephant 8
25 The Truth 9
26 Thief of Time 10
27 The Last Hero 7
28 The Amazing Maurice and his Educated Rodents 9
29 Night Watch 8
30 The Wee Free Men 10
31 Monstrous Regiment 6
32 A Hat Full of Sky 8
33 Going Postal 10
34 Thud! 8
35 Wintersmith 7
36 Making Money 6
37 Unseen Academicals 7
38 I Shall Wear Midnight 8

Willem wrote:While I respect your personal opinions and decisions on this, I would like to advise you on changing your scale. If you think an 'average' book deserves a 7.5 you've been very lucky in your reading materialYou've probably got reader's bias (you're reading stuff you know you like, meaning your scores will be on the high end anyhow). I'm predicting a lot of 8-8.5-9 scores which honestly doesn't make for a very interesting list. Compare tv.com, where people can rate episodes of shows. Usually, episodes will score very, very high over there because it's mostly fans rating them. Fans will often rate a bad episode higher than deserved, because, well, they're fans.
Quatermass wrote:Willem wrote:While I respect your personal opinions and decisions on this, I would like to advise you on changing your scale. If you think an 'average' book deserves a 7.5 you've been very lucky in your reading materialYou've probably got reader's bias (you're reading stuff you know you like, meaning your scores will be on the high end anyhow). I'm predicting a lot of 8-8.5-9 scores which honestly doesn't make for a very interesting list. Compare tv.com, where people can rate episodes of shows. Usually, episodes will score very, very high over there because it's mostly fans rating them. Fans will often rate a bad episode higher than deserved, because, well, they're fans.
....
Your point?
I'm not lucky about my reading material. I'm mostly picky about it. So what if I have reader's bias? The score is based on my entertainment value.
Quatermass wrote:.......
So is there any point to me doing this at all? Well? Should I continue? I don't see any point now, really. You two in particular just killed my interest in re-reading the Discworld series, all because you nitpick about the way I rate things! This is how I rate all books I read!
Thank you very much for killing this thread, you two. I hope that you're happy. If you're going to comment about my scale and not my actual arguments as to why they deserve it, then I see no point in continuing. At least Tony made interesting points...

Users browsing this forum: Bing [Bot], josiefletcher and 3 guests